profile 박찬호 2008-08-12 15:26:41
5 560
용접 Category 중 "E"가 있는지요?

A~D는 알겠는데 "E"는 어디를 의미하는지 궁금합니다.

이진희 2008-08-13 13:49

E도 있고,F도 있습니다.

관련 문헌을 좀더 찾아 보시기 바랍니다.

Thomas Eun 2008-08-14 09:17

ASME Sec.VIII has four joint categories (A to D) for pressure retaining parts.
As you know the joint categories are based on the possibility of failure by stress mode of Timosenko Theory.
They have different requirements for NDE, joint efficient (for strength calculation), and PWHT according to the weakest joint "A" (long seam in shell) through the most safety joint "D" (shell to nozzle). See the attachment.

The joint E & F are not controlled by ASME Sec. VIII. However most manufacturers are using the joint categories for their QA-QC program for all weld joints on pressure vessel. For instance, Joint E may be for reinforcement pad to shell in semi-pressure boundary while Joint F may be for non pressure boundary (i.e., skirt/saddle parts).

Meanwhile AWS D1.1 (Structural Welding Code-Steel) has some different categories (stress category) which are based on the possibility of failure by fatigue stress. It is completely different concept from that of ASME Sec. VIII.
The collapse of Sungsoo Bridge was caused by the violation of the stress category application (design vs. actual).

박찬호 2008-08-13 16:08

ASME VIII Div.1에는 Category A~D 까지만 나오고 그이상은
찾을 수가 없는데, 관련문헌을 알려주시거나,
직접 Category E에 대해 설명해 주시면 감사하겠습니다.

Thomas Eun 2008-08-14 13:11

이진희 2008-08-13 17:46

AWS D1.1의 Table 2.4를 보시면 자세히 나와 있습니다.

아시는 바와 같이 ASME에서는 달랑 D까지만 나와 있는 데, ASHHTO나 AISC, AWS등에서는 좀더 다양하게 구분하고 있습니다.

(주)테크노넷|대표. 이진희|사업자등록번호. 757-88-00915|이메일. technonet@naver.com|개인정보관리책임자. 이진희

대표전화. 070-4709-3241|통신판매업. 2021-서울금천-2367|주소. 서울시 금천구 벚꽃로 254 월드메르디앙 1차 401호

Copyright ⓒ Technonet All rights Reserved.